Who watches the watchmen?

The recent NSE fiasco indicates a larger systemic problem: there is a general malaise, seeping deep among India’s sectoral regulators.

7 March, 20229 min
0
Google Preferred Source Badge
Share
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
Who watches the watchmen?

Why read this story?

Editor's note: By now, you might have heard that the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has finally passed its order after looking into the major irregularities—suspicious appointments, trips to tax havens by senior management, preferential access to certain brokers, mysterious emails from yogis, etc.—at the National Stock Exchange (NSE). It is a different matter that the order is far from satisfactory and comes more than six years after the initial complaints were made to SEBI and long after a series of investigative reports by Moneylife—the consumer advocacy organization that brought NSE’s lapses into public discourse. It is disappointing, yes, but hardly surprising. And unfortunately so. India’s securities market regulator has repeatedly dragged its feet on revelations of major securities fraud (read Satyam, Sahara, Reliance Capital), and has had its supposed regulatory independence compromised in various ways—either through internecine jurisdictional conflicts within the government (with the Reserve Bank of India, or RBI, the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India, IRDAI, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs, the Ministry of Finance, etc.) or through a general struggle to convert complaints into meaningful …

You may also like

Chaos
Story image

Why UAE’s stability premium is under question

For years, the country has been insulated from West Asia’s conflicts. Six days into the Iran war, that status is under strain—and investors could be recalibrating.

Business
Story image

A chaotic week for Adani group speaks volumes about India’s energy scene

From crippling solar tariffs and a sovereign fund exit to revived power contracts, a turbulent week highlights the group’s contested yet indispensable role in India’s energy transition.

Business
Story image

SEBI’s overdue expansion is underway, but top-level gaps persist

India’s market regulator is looking to ramp up hiring at the entry level. But what really needs attention is the constant uncertainty at the top and the lack of domain experts.