Friction #18: Franklin Templeton’s brokerage puzzle and Mistry coming off second best in fight with Tatas

Franklin Templeton's unpaid brokerage in the six debt schemes is another unsolved puzzle. The futility of the legal fight between Tata Group and Mistry clan.

Jayshree P. Upadhyay

Mumbai

05 April 2021

You can always update your display preferences in Settings menu

If you thought there were no more skeletons left in Franklin Templeton India’s closet, you need to think again. Having written a fair bit on the unethical behavior of its top management and fund managers in the run-up to the closure of its six debt mutual fund schemes, even I thought I was done with the asset management company for a while. But there is some new information that’s come to light. We will get to it in a bit.

I’d like to state at the outset that the Rs 15,000-odd crore which has come into Franklin Templeton’s six wound up schemes through prepayments, maturities and sales can, by no means, be discounted. However, the narrative needs some course correction here. Returning money to investors without haircuts is not a favour but the bare minimum expected of an AMC. And, by no stretch of imagination, does it give it a clean bill of health with regard to mismanagement and unethical behavior.

The other big event of the past fortnight from this

What our readers say

Why subscribers love The Morning Context

Research ideas don't come from a vacuum. The best ideas come from a spark, a contrarian take, an uncommon investigative insight, and one doesn't always get these from traditional media. TMC consistently makes me think about things in different ways, and I've frequently shared TMC articles with collaborators and students. Staying at the cutting edge is hard enough; TMC makes it much easier.

Rohit Chandra, Assistant Professor - School of Public Policy (IIT Delhi)

High quality, independent journalism is rare to find. The Morning Context set really high standards that make me wait for each story.

Abhay Pandey, Managing partner, A91 Capital

Well-written and researched long form reads on a wide variety of topics and a team of veteran journalists - all of this makes my subscription worth it.

Anupam Gupta, Investment research consultant

In today's very noisy and cluttered world, I like that the Morning Context goes below the surface of company PR to deliver fact-based stories on Indian business.

Jessie Paul, CEO, Paul Writer

The Morning Context is my daily opportunity to get smarter about one new company/sector. Discerning analysis, unbiased and approachable.

Miten Sampat, Angel investor & former CSO, Times Internet

In today's polarized world, authentic and unbiased facts are in short supply world over. The Morning Context is a refreshing approach towards truthful, well researched, fearless, and high-quality articles on contemporary topics.

N S Parthasarthy, Co-founder, Mindtree

In a world full of noise, The Morning Context is the calm that stimulates and energises your mind, with stories focused on fact, truth and dogged reportage.

Nikhil Taneja, Co-founder and CEO, Yuvaa

Although it’s a paid subscription, the kind of detailed research and quality of reportage makes it worth every rupee. It’s strength surely lies in having some of the finest journalists writing for it.

Shiladitya Bora, Producer, distributor and founder at Platoon One Films

As one of the early subscribers, I've had the opportunity to witness how quickly the team has grown, the variety of angles covered, and the research in every in-depth story and op-ed.

Amarjit Batra, Managing director, Spotify India